The woman, who introduced herself as Palwasha from Lakki Marwat, a conservative town in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, asked about the social issues plaguing her community.
She mentioned that while the men in her society are regular mosque-goers and women stay indoors unless necessary, the area faces rampant issues like drug addiction, pedophilia, and adultery.
She questioned why religious scholars weren’t addressing these problems, especially pedophilia.
Dr. Naik’s initial response was a joke, saying that like the women in her society, “he himself doesn’t leave the house unless needed,” adding that men should also stay home if there’s no need to go out.
He then claimed her question was contradictory, as she described her community as religious while also acknowledging these serious social issues. Dr. Naik suggested she should seek forgiveness for asking such a question.
When Palwasha attempted to clarify that the individuals involved in these issues were the same people attending mosques, Dr. Naik interrupted her, insisting her question was wrong and becoming more dismissive as the exchange continued. At one point, he bluntly told her to let him speak.
The video, shared on Dr. Naik’s X (formerly Twitter) account with the caption “Pathan Girl asks Dr Zakir Naik a contradictory question about Pakistani society,” sparked outrage online, with many criticizing his tone and approach.
Veteran journalist Abbas Nasir condemned Dr. Naik for using the term “Pathan girl” in the caption, accusing him of self-righteous behavior.
Nazrana Yousufzai, a Twitter user, called the interaction “deflection, insult, and bullying of a young student.”
Another user, Faran Manj, pointed out that Dr. Naik’s response discouraged Palwasha from asking such questions in the future and insulted her in the process.
Dr. Maryam labeled the response as bullying, suggesting Dr. Naik had no real answer to the question, while Hassan Saeed praised Palwasha’s question as “brilliant” and called out Dr. Naik for belittling her.
WhatsApp Channel
ChatGPT
Instagram
Facebook
X (Twitter)
Support the officially authentic Islamic website.
Support our mission to spread Islamic knowledge. Your donation helps our volunteer writers and infrastructure. Contribute now.
Discover more from The Islamic Information
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
The question was obviously contradictory while claiming that it is a conservative village, men being pious and women confined to their homes on the other hand pedophilia and adultery was rampant and religious scholars are silent. It cannot be so as women cannot be silent spectators in such a situation. Only visiting the village and proper enquiry will only reveal the actual situation. The religious heads of the village will also not remain silent. It seems she does not know how to frame the question and what she actually wants to know. Dr. Naik could have dealt the question more tactfully with his large experience in public discourses. May be he was under stress and lost his temper which could have been avoided. This led to unnecessary controversy.
zakir naik has become an absolute nuisance for Islam.
There are multitudes of Islamic Scholars much more knowledgeable than him who are so graceful in answering questions from the audience.
I feel zakir naik must be forced to apologize to that girl.
Dr Zakir Nail must apologise to the lady.
Her question was contradictory. You can’t be religious, at the same time involve in drugs, adultery etc.
Religious persons always distance their selves from such satanic activities.
2). How many people she can surely identified practicing such illegal and immoral acts ?
3). Those accusing Dr Zakir Naik on media, did so for their selfishness. Most of them are likely influenced by Western false “human rights” .
4). In Islam , though you can ask , but not SILLY questions.